Welcome to The Wheelchair Site Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Wheels in the City

Do Words Really Matter?

When people mean well, but say the wrong thing

I once heard a wheelchair-using comedian speak on terminology. He said in the 1940's he was known as “crippled”; in the 1950's he was called “handicapped”; in the 1960's he was considered “confined to a wheelchair”; in the 1970's he was plain “disabled”; in the 1980's he was “a person with a disability”; and now he's considered “differently-abled.” In the punch line, he predicted that in 10-years he would be called “normal.” I don't remember what his name was, but his take on the ridiculous evolution of politically correct terminology really stuck with me.

The expectation that society will stay on the politically correct bandwagon is just as comical. I mean, I already find some of the newer terms to be more demeaning than the older ones. In particular, the term “differently-abled” makes me feel like an alien with super powers rather than a normal person with some gifts, talents and a few physical limitations.

So if the acceptance of various terms depends on personal viewpoints - how can we deal with the terms we find particularly offensive? There are a number of options that I'd like to discuss.

First, righteous indignance may be justifiable, because after all in some cases it's good to speak out. However, this approach may leave you looking bitter over someone else's honest mistake, and this can make the situation unduly awkward and embarrassing for everyone involved.

Another option is adopting derogatory terms into your plain speech. This may empower you in the same way that it seems to empower other social and racial groups. After all, the more that shocking terms are used in everyday conversation; the more they begin to lose significance right? The problem with this is that not everyone will realize your objective, and you risk offending those who think these terms contribute to mixed messages or those that just plain won't tolerate derogatory lingo.

My approach is to explain my point of view to the people I know well. In my experience there are few negative effects when you explain your personal opinions to the people closest to you. After all, they are the least likely to feel threatened or get the wrong impression by your intimate conversation. Through word of mouth they will likely share your point of view with others, and your message will spread.

Above all, if someone else's language bothers you, don't ignore it. However, when identifying and trying to solve the conflict, keep the speakers' intentions in mind as well as the context of your conversation. Always remember that people usually mean well – even when they say the wrong thing.

Keep on rolling in the city.

~ Chantal

Published Friday, July 07, 2006 5:23 PM by Chantal

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

 

Barb said:

I have always found that speaking about my disabilities and what life is like for me in a chair is the most empowering thing.

Knowlege is power - it almost never fails - if I talk to people about my expriences I cease to be a "handicapped person" and become just a "person".

Keep on rolling Chantal and telling it like it is!
August 28, 2006 2:35 PM
 

Eric said:

It's good getting this kind of perspective. Even writing this comment, I encounter difficulty describing myself: a person who isn't differently abled? a person without a disability? a person not using a wheelchair?

The truth is, while a person's wheelchair and physical abilities/limitations plays a significant role in their lives, in the lives of people who don't regularly encounter people who are "differently abled," there's no incentive to keep track of the latest, politically correct terminology. Communities from all different walks of life have preferred terminology - which is legitimate - but it would take a very concerted effort for a person who doesn't encounter people from these communities in their daily life to stay on top of the correct ones for all of these groups. People aren't trying to be insulting when they use the "wrong" terminology. In most cases, they either don't know the correct term, or they haven't been told the rationale for why the term they are using is inappropriate. Being offended by this misues of language is futile - just politely tell the offender, in a friendly tone of voice, that you would "really prefer" different terminology to be used, and be open to explaining the reason if they express genuine surprise or bafflement.  

PS: I still don't know if "disability" is offensive.
March 23, 2007 2:43 PM

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit